IW¡pIÄ
sImv amkw ImWnsöv t_m[ys¸« Znhkw amkw IXmbn km£nIÄ hyàam¡nbm {]kvXpX
km£nXzw AwKoIcn¡s¸Sptam? F¶ tNmZyw {]kàamWv. km£nXzw XÅn¡fbWsa¶ 'DºmZn(d)bpsS
hm¡pIÄ D²cn¨ tijw AXv icnsh¡pIbmWv _lp. JzÂbq_n(d) sNbvXncn¡p¶sX¶v Nne
BfpIÄ hmZn¡p¶p.
\ap¡v ]WvVnX·mcpsS
hm¡pIÄ ]cntim[n¡mw. ssiJv apl½Zp±nwbmXzn(d) ]dbp¶p: ""\oXnamsâ
km£nsamgn Ahew_n¨v Jzmfzn¡v amk¸ndhn \nÝbn¡mw. km£nXzw (ilmZXv) tIhew
Hcp hm¡msW¦nepw AXhew_n¡m hp¶XmWv. C_v\p 'Dadn(d)sâ lZokn CXv hyàam¡p¶pv.
C_v\p 'DaÀ(d) ]dªp: ""Rm³ amk¸ndhn IXmbn \_n(kz)sb Adnbn¨t¸mÄ \_n(kz)
AX\pkcn¨v t\m¼\pjvTn¡pIbpw P\§tfmSv t\m¼\pjvTn¡m³ I¸n¡pIbpw sNbvXp.''
IW¡pIÄ ASnØm\am¡n tKmfimkv{XÚ·mÀ amkw Im Wnsöp]dªm AXv ]cnKW\obaÃ.
Cu hm¡pIÄ ]cnKWn¨v km£nIfpsS samgn kzoIcn¡s¸SpIbnsö JzÂbq_n(d)bpsS
A`n{]mbs¯ FXnÀ ¯psImmWv Rm\nXv ]dbp¶Xv' (A±eoep¯mw Aem apÀinZn A\mw
2/170).
^XvlpÂ
AÃmw ]dbp¶p: ""im^n'Cu aZvl_v {]Imcw JzÂbq_n(d)bpsS A`n{]mbw ]cnKW\obaÃ.
IW¡pIÄs¡XnscbpÅ km£nXzw kzoIcn¡s¸Spsa¶XmWv im^n'Cu aZvl_n ]cnKW\obambXv''
(^Xvlp AÃmw 2/171).
'DºmZn(d)bpsS
A`n{]mbw icnsh¨ asämcp hyànbmWv Camw kp_vIn(d). Camw kp_vIn(d)bpsS
A`n{]mbs¯ JWvUn¨psImv Camw dwen(d) FgpXp¶p: ""IW¡ns\ \_n(kz)
Ahew_n¨n«nÃ. {]XypX, AhKWn¡pIbmWpmbXv. AXpkw_Ôambn ico'A¯nsâ hn[nbpw
asäm¶Ã. Xsâ ]nXmhv A{]Imcw ^Xvh \ÂInbn«papv'' (\nlmb 3/153 C{]Imcw
apKv\n 1/421epw ImWmw).
Camw
dwen(d) Xs¶ ]dbs«. ""kp_vIn(d)bpsS hm¡v XÅs¸«XmIp¶p. ]n ¡me ]WvVnX·mcnÂ
Hcp kwLw BfpIÄ Xs¶ kp_vIn(d)bpsS hm¡ns\ FXnÀ¯ncn¡pIbmWv. CXnsâ \ymbw
\_n(kz) IW¡ns\ Ahew_am¡nbn«nÃ, {]XypX, ]qÀWambpw AhKWn¡pIbmWv sNbvXsX¶mWv.
\_n(kz) ]dªp: ""\mw Fgp¯pw IW¡panÃm¯ kaqlamWv'' (^Xmhm dwen lmanip ^XmhÂ
Ip_vd 2/59).
F¶m C_v\plPÀ(d)
]dbp¶Xv ImWpI: ""IW¡n\v \nZm\am¡p¶ ASnØm\ XXz§Ä kwibclnXamsW¶v
AXpkw_Ôambn ]cnÚm\apÅhÀ GtIm]n¡pIbpw Ahcn \n¶v C¡mcyw D²cn¡p¶hÀ
AZZp¯hmXpÀ (AkXy¯n sFIyamIm³ km[yXbnÃm¯ F®w) DmhpIbpw sNbvXm km£nsamgn
XtÅXpw AÃm¯ ]£w km£nsamgn XÅm³ ]mSnÃm¯XpamsW¶mWv {]_eambXv. Cu
hniZoIcWamWv \ncp]m[nIambn km£nXzw XÅWsa¶ kp_vIn(d)bpsSbpw \ncp]m[nIw
km£nXzw kzoIcn¡Wsa¶ aäpÅhcpsSbpw A`n{]mbs¯¡mÄ A\ptbmPyambXv'' (Xplv^
3/382, 383)
apIfnep²cn¨ C_v\plPdn(d)sâ hm¡pIsf JWvUn¨ C_v\pJzmknan(d)\v _lp. iÀhm\n(d)
adp]Sn \ÂIp¶pv. C_v\plPÀ(d)hnsâ ta hm¡pIÄ _lp. iÀhm\n(d) hymJym\n¡p¶Xv
ImWpI. ""km£nXzw aptJ\ e`n¡p¶ t_m[ys¯¡mÄ anI¨Xpw Dd¸nse¡Sp¯Xpamb
t_m[yw AZZp¯hmXpÀ(AkXy¯n tbmPn¡Â Akm[yamb F®w) F¯n¨hcpsS dnt¸mÀ«v hgn
IcØambm AXv km£nXzw XÅp¶Xn\v ]cym]vXamIp¶p'' (lminbXpiÀhm\n 3/382).
Cu
hniZoIcW {]Imcw _lp. C_v\plPÀ(d) ]dª cv D]m[nIÄ Hcpan¨pIqSpI A{X
Ffp¸aÃ. Camw IpÀZn(d)bpsS hm¡pIÄ {it²bamWv. ""IW¡n\v Ahew_am¡nb ASnØm\
XXz§Ä JWvUnXamsW¶v IW¡pImscÃmw GtIm]n¨mepw Ahcn \n¶v {]kvXpX Imcyw
D²cn¡p¶hÀ AZZp¯hmXpÀ F¯n¡epw \n_Ô\bmsW¶v ]dªXv Imcys¯ eLqIcn¡p¶pv.
FhnsS\n¶mWv C¸dª \n_Ô\IÄ kwtbmP¡pI'' (^Xmh IpÀZn t]Pv 78).
AX{X
Ffp¸aÃm¯Xv sImv Xs¶bmWv C_v\plPÀ(d) Xs¶ iÀlp 'D_m_n C§s\ ]dªXv ""Cu
]dª \n_Ô\IsfÃmw H¯pIqSnsb¶p k ¦Â¸n¡s¸«m amkw Incn¡p¶psh¶ km£nXzw
kzoIcn¡s¸SpIbnÃ'' (lminbXpiÀhm\n 3/374 t\m¡pI).
D]cypà \n_Ô\IÄ
Hcpan¨pIqSpI F¶Xv tIhew km¦Â¸nIw am{XamWv. C¡mcyw C_v\plPdn(d)sâ
D]cypà hm¡pIÄ Xs¶ hyàam¡p¶pv. ImcWw IW¡pIfpsS am\ZWvUambn kzoIcn¡s¸Sp¶
\nZm\ XXz§Ä apgph\pw JWvUnXambn Øncs¸«XmsW¶v Cu hnÚm\ imJbpambn _Ôs¸«
]WvVnX·mÀ Xs¶ ]dbp¶nÃ.
PkocnbpsS hm¡pIÄ ImWpI: ""tKmfimkv{XÚ·mcpsS {]hN\§Ä¡v \nZm \w hfsc
KmVamb XXz§fmsW¦nepw an¡ kab¯pw AhcpsS A`n{]mb§Ä IrXyamImsXbmWv \mw
ImWp¶Xv. A[nIkab§fnepw AhcpsS A`n{]mb§Ä hyXykvXamIp¶Xv CXn\v sXfnhmWv''
(A aZmln_p AÀ_'A, 1/500).
F¶m GXm\pw
\nZm\§fn GtIm]nXcmb ]WvVnX·mÀ Xs¶ AZZp¯hmXpÀ DÅhcpaÃ. AXn\m GsX¦nepw
NnecpsS IW¡pIÄ Ahew_n¨v km£nXzw XÅp¶Xv \ymboIcn¡mhXÃ. AXv im^n'Cu
aZvl_nse {][m\ {KÙ§fmb Xplv^, \nlmb, apKv\n XpS§nb {KÙ§fpsS GIIWvTamb
Xocpam\¯n\v FXncmWv.
im^n'Cu
aZvl_n asäÃm A`n{]mb§Ä¡pap]cn Xplv^bpsSbpw \nlmbbpsSbpw GtIm]\amWv
AwKoIcn¡s¸SpI. Xplv^¡pw \nlmb¡psaXncn {]ISn¸n¡s¸Sp¶ CXc A`n{]mb§Ä¡v
im^n'Cu aZvl_n AwKoImcansöv kmcw. A ^hmCZp aZ\n¿ t]Pv 44 CXv
hyàam¡nbn«pv.
F¶m CXv
Xs¶bmWv aäv aZvl_nsâ ]WvVnX·mcpsSbpw ]£w. l\^o IÀaimkv{X ]WvVnX\mb _lp.
C_v\p 'B_nZo³(d) ]dbp¶p. ""im^n'Cu ]WvVnX\mb Camw kp_vIn(d)¡v Hcp cN\bpv.
IW¡v Ahew_am¡msa¶Xnte¡mWv AXnsâ Nmbvhv. IW¡v JWvUnXamsW¶XmWv AXn\v
ImcWambn kp_vIn(d) ]dbp¶Xv. F¶m Rm³ ]dbs«. kp_vIn(d) ]dªXns\ At±l¯nsâ
aZvl_pImcmb ]n¡me ]WvVnX·mÀ Xs¶ FXnÀ¯ncn¡pIbmWv. C_v\plPdpw(d)
dwen(d)bpw AhcnÂs¸Spw'' (d±p aplvXmÀ 2/141).
amenIo
aZvl_nse IÀaimkv{X ]WvVnX\mb Camw J¯zm_v(d) ]dbp¶Xv Im WpI. ""amk¸ndhn
ZÀin¨Xmbn km£nIÄ samgnbpIbpw IW¡pImÀ ZÀi\¯n\v km[yXbnsöv JWvUnXambn ]dbpIbpw
sNbvXm \½psS ]WvVnXcpsS hm¡pIfn \n¶v hyàamIp¶Xv IW¡pImcpsS hm¡v ]cnKW\obasömWv'
(ahmln_p Peo 2/388).
GsX¦nepw
hyànIfpsS IW¡pIÄ ASnØm\am¡n JmfznamÀ AhcpsS AcnIn Øncs¸« km£nsamgn
XÅn¡fbWsa¶ P¸\w aZvl_pIÄ¡pw aäp ]WvVnX·mÀ¡pw hncp²amsW¶v taÂ
hniZoIcW¯n \n¶v hyàambn. F ¶m km£nbpsS samgn AwKoIcn¡Wsa¦n dafzm³,
Asæn i'Av_m³ 29 AkvXan¨ tijw \át\{X§Ä sImv Xs¶ amk¸ndhn ZÀin¨ncn¡Ww.
{]XyX I®mSn, shÅw, ¥mkv, ZqcZÀin\n XpS§nbh D]tbmKn¨v sImpÅ ImgvN¡v
bmsXmcp ]cnKW\bpanÃ'' (Xplv^ iÀhm\n klnXw 3/372 t\m¡pI).
AbÂcmPy¡mÀ¡pw hn[n _m[Iw
Hcp {]tZi¯v
amk¸ndhn ZÀi\apmbm AXnt\mSv ASp¯p \n¡p¶ cmPy§Ä¡pw B hn[n _m[IamIp¶XmWv.
DZb§Ä hyXymkamIepw BImXncn¡epamWv cmPy§Ä ]ckv]cw ASp¸¯nepw
AI¨bnepamIp¶Xnsâ am\ZWvUw. Cu A`n{]mbamWv {]_eambXv. Camw \hhn(d)
an³lmPn {]kvXmhn¨XmWn¡mcyw.
Cu
hm¡pIÄ hniZoIcn¨psImv C_v\plPÀ(d) FgpXp¶p: ""DZbmkvXab§Ä hyXymkamIp¶Xnepw
BImXncn¡p¶Xnepw tKmfimkv{XÚ·msc hn[n IÀ¯m¡fm¡mhp¶XmWv. Chsc
hn[nIÀ¯m¡fm¡m³ ]mSnsöv ]dbp¶Xv ASnØm\ {]amW§fn am{XamWv. A\p_Ô§fneÃ.
DZbhyXymkw IW¡m¡Â Cu A\p_Ô§fnÂs¸«XmWv ({hXw \nÀ_ÔamIp¶Xn\v ASnØm\]cambn
Ahsc Ahew_n¡m³ ]mSnsænepw Hcp cmPy¯pÅhÀ¡v t\m¼v \nÀ_Ôambm AtXmS\p_Ôn¨v
Ab cmPy¡mÀ¡pw AXv _m[IamIpsa¶ hnjb¯n Ahsc hn[nIÀ¯m¡fm¡msa¶v Npcp¡w).
F¶m Hcp cmPy¯v ZÀin¡s¸«Xp sImv atä cmPy¯v ZÀin¡m\pÅ km[yX hncfamIamIpw
hn[w cv cmPy§fpw AI¶ncn¡emWv DZb§Ä hyXymkamIp¶Xv sImpÅ hnh£sb¶v
A³hmdn {]kvXmhn¨n«pv'' (Xplv^ 3/381).
CX\pkcn¨v
DZbhyXymkw IW¡m¡m³ tPymÕy·msc B{ibnt¡n hcp¶nÃ. CXpsImpXs¶bmWv
DZbhyXymk¯n\v Ahew_ambn ^Xvlp apCu³ t]Pv 187 A³hmdnsâ hm¡v
am{Xap²cn¨Xv.
C_v\plPÀ(d)
]dbp¶p: ""Hcp cmPy¯v amk¸ndhn ZÀin¨m AXnsâ ASp¯ cmPy¡mÀ¡pw taÂhn[n _m[IamIpsa¶v
]dªXnsâ XmXv]cyw {]kvXpX cmPy¯v ZÀin¡Â sImv am{Xw AbÂcmPy¡mÀ¡pw
t\m¼pw s]cp¶mfpsaÃmw \nÀ_ÔamIpsa¶mWv. ]t£, Nt{µmZbw ZÀin¨Xmbn P\kwkmcapÅ
cmPy¯v (Jzmfzn aptJ\tbm atäm) dafzm³ Øncs¸«n«nsæn amk¸ndhn ZÀin¨Xmbn
]dbp¶hsc hnizkn¡p¶ AbÂcmPy¡mcn \n¶pÅhÀ¡v am{Xw {hXsaSp¡Â \nÀ_ÔamIp¶Xpw
AhcÃm¯hÀ¡v \nÀ_ÔamIm¯XpamIp¶p. {]kvXpX cmPy¯v dafzm³ Øncs¸«n«ps¦nÂ
AXnsâ AbÂcmPy¡mÀ¡pw dafzm³ Øncs¸Sp¶XmWv. ]t£, AbÂcmPy¡mÀ¡v {]kvXpX Øn
coIcWadnbm\pÅ amÀKapmbncn¡Â A\nhmcyamWv. (JzmfznbpsS) hn[n{]Jym]\w
sImmWv {]kvXpX cmPy¯v dafzm³ Øncs¸«sX¦n AbÂcmPys¯ JzmfznbpsS AcnInÂ
{]kvXpX Jzmfzn hn[n {]Jym]n¨Xmbn cpt]À km£n \n¡emWv {]kvXpX amÀK§fnÂ
H¶v. HcmÄ am{Xw km£n \n¶m aXnbmInÃ. BZys¯ Jzmfzn hn[n {]Jym]n¡m³ Hcp
km£n am{Xw aXnsb¶v ]dbp¶Xv t\m¼v sImv hn[n¡m\mWv. cmas¯ Jzmfzn t\m¼v
sImv hn[n¡pIbÃtÃm. {]XypX, amkw I cmPys¯ Jzmfzn hn[n¨Xmbn
ØncoIcn¡pIbmWv. Nt{µmZbw ZÀin¨Xmbn {]kn²nbmÀPn¡Â sImv {]kvXpX cmPy¯v
dafzm³ Øncs¸«Xmbn Ab {]tZis¯ JzmfznbpsS AcnIn cpt]À km£n\n¡emWv
cmas¯ amÀKw'' (Xplv^ 3/380).
amk¸ndhn
ZÀin¨Xmbn {]kn²nbmÀPn¡Â sImv am{Xw B cmPy¯v s]mXphmbn t\m¼\pjvTn¡Â \nÀ_ÔamIpsa¶v
cmaXv ]dª amÀK¯n \n¶v hyàamIp¶Xmbn _lp. iÀhm\n(d) Xplv^bpsS hymJym\¯nÂ
tcJs¸Sp¯nbn«pv. Npcp¡¯n amkw I cmPy¯p Xs¶ s]mXphmbn t\m¼v \nÀ_ÔamIWsa¦nÂ
B \m«nse Jzmfzn hn[n {]Jym]n¡pItbm amkw IXmbn P\§Ä¡nSbnÂ
{]kn²nbmÀPn¡pItbm sNt¿XmWv.
_lp.
ssiJv aJvZqw(d) FgpXp¶p: ""JzmfznbpsS AcnIn dafzm³ amk¸ndhn ZÀin¨Xmbn
\oXnam\mb Hcp hyànbpsS k£nXzw aptJ\ Øncs¸SpIbpw AX\pkcn¨v Fsâ AcnInÂ
dafzm³ Øncs¸«ncn¡p¶psh¶v Jzmfzn {]Jym]n¡pIbpw sNbvXm B cmPy¡mÀ¡v
apgps¡bpw t\m¼v \nÀ_ÔamIp¶XmWv. C{]Imcw Xs¶bmWv amk¸ndhn Incn¡p¶psh¶
apXhmXndmb (A\ntj[yamwhn[w {]kn²amb) hnhchpw. Cu Adnhv AapkvenwIfnÂ
\n¶msW¦nepw icn. CXpaptJ\ \ntj[n¡m\mIm¯ hn[apÅ Adnhv e`n¡p¶ps¶XmWv
ImcWw'' (^XvlpÂap'Cu³, t]Pv 187).
AbÂcmPys¯
Jzmfzn¡v X¡Xmb Ahew_aSnØm\am¡nbpÅ Adnshm¶pw e`n¡m¯ kmlNcy¯n ta¸dª
GXv amÀK¯nembncp¶mepw cv km £nIÄ aptJ\bpÅ hnhcw e`n¨meÃmsX hn[n
{]Jym]n¡m³ hgnbnÃ.
""amk¸ndhn
ZÀin¨ cmPy¯v {]kvXpX cv amÀK§fneqsS t\m¼v s]mXphmbn \nÀ_Ôambn«nsænepw
ZÀin¨hÀ¡pw Ahsc hnizkn¡p¶hÀ¡pw t\m¼\pjvTn¡Â \nÀ_ÔamIpw. ZÀin¨ hyàn
km£n¡v ]äm¯h\mbmepw icn. AXpt]mse Xs¶ Xsâ cmPys¯ At]£n¨v DZbhyXymkanÃm¯
cmPy¯v dafzm³ Øncs¸«Xmbn ]dbp¶ hyànsb hmkvXham¡p¶h\pw {hXsaSp¡Â \nÀ_ÔamIpw.
s]cp¶mfnsâ Imcyhpw XssYh'' (Xplv^ 3/379).
|