CPvXnlmZv F¶m F´v?
\n_Ô\sbmŻ IŔ˝ imkv{X ]WvVnXł
(^Jolv) lpIvav (hn[n) kw_Ôambn Hcp `mh\bnseŻp¶Xn\v thn Xsâ FĂm ]cn{ia§fpw
\oˇnshˇp¶Xn\mWv CPvXnlmZv F¶v ]dbp¶Xv (PwDÂ PhmanAv 2:379).
Ft¸mgmWv CPvXnlmZv A\nhmcyamhpI?
FĂm Imcy§fpw DÄsˇm JpŔB\pw
lZokpw \˝psS ssIhiaps¦nepw ]e Imcy§fpw {]XyŁambn Ahbn hyŕamˇnbn«nĂ.
JpŔB\nepw kp¶Żnepw ] dŞ hym]ImŔYapĹ {]tbmK§fn \n¶pw Ah IsŻpIbmWv
thXv. cn sâbpw _mly {]tbmK§fn \n¶v Ah a\Ęnemˇmł km[yamhpIbnĂ. \_n (kz)
]dŞp: ""A\phZnˇs¸«Xpw \njn˛amˇ¸«Xpamb (Ipsd) Imcy§Ä hyŕ amWv. CXv cn\panSbnÂ
hn[nIÄ Xncn¨dnbm\mImŻ Nne hnjb§fpv. P\ §fn `qcn]ŁŻn\pw AXdnbnĂ'' (_pJmcn).
Camw C_v\p lPŔ (d) Cu lZokv
C§s\ hymJym\nˇp¶p. ""\nŔ®bamb hn[n hyŕamImŻXnt\mSv AXv kmayambXv sImv
Xncn¨dnbmsXbmbncnˇp¶p. P\§fn `qcn]ŁŻn\pw AXv "lemenÂ' s]«tXm "ldmanÂ'
s]«tXm F¶ dnbnĂ. A[nIt]Ŕˇpw AdnbnsöXnsâ XmÂ]cyw AhbpsS hn[nIÄ
Ipd¨pt]Ŕ sˇ¦nepw Adnbpsa¶mWv. AhcmWv apPvXlnZpIÄ'' (^Xvlp _mcn
1:127). Cu kmlNcyŻn hn[nIÄ IsŻmł CPvXnlmZv am{XamWv hgn.
FĂm hnjb§fpsSbpw \nŔ®mbI hn[n
DÄsˇmĹp¶ JpŔB\nepw AXnsâ hym Jym\amb kp¶Żnepw,B[p\nIbpKŻnÂ
Dmbnsˇmncnˇp¶ ]pXnb ]pXnb hnjb§sf kw_Ôn¨v hyŕambn ]dbmXncnˇptĽmÄ
Ckvemw kĽqŔ®a söv ]dtbnhcpw. temIŻv \Sˇm\ncnˇp¶ GsXmcp hnjbŻnsâbpw
hn[n IÄ apPvXlnZpIÄ hc¨p Im«nbn«pv. temIŻv \Sˇm\ncnˇp¶ GsXmcp hnjb Żnsâbpw
hn[n AhŔ ]cmaŔinˇmsX t]mbn«nĂ. CXv Camap ldssa\n (d) Xs¶ {]kvXmhn¨n«pv.
`{Zamb ASnŘm\ \nba§fpw hym]vXn IqSnb [mcmfw hniZoIcW§fpw AhŔ tcJs¸SpŻn
sh¨Xn\m tijapmIp¶ bmsXmcp {]iv\Żn\pw ]cnlmcw IsŻmł ]n¡me ]WvVnXŔˇv
{]bmks¸tSn hcnĂ. FĂm apPvXlnZpIfpsSbpw Imetijw, C¶v Pohnˇp¶
kaqlŻnepm Ip¶ ]pXnb {]iv\§Äˇv ]cnlmcw ImtWXv IŔ˝ imkv{X {K٧fn \S
Żp¶ "_lvkv' aptJ\bmWv.
sXfnhpIfn ImWp¶ sshcp˛yw
CPvXnlmZv A\nhmcyamˇp¶ asämcp
LSIamWv sXfnhpIfn ImWp¶ ssh cp˛yw. Nne hnjb§fn sXfnhpIÄ ]ckv]cw
FXncmb cq]Żn ImWmhp¶ XmWv. ChnsS cv sXfnhpIfpw icnbmsW¦nepw cnsem¶v
btYjvSw XncsŞ Spˇmł ]mSnĂ. Cu XncsŞSp¸mWv CPvXnlmZv. CXn\p Ipsd
tbmKyXIÄ Dm bncnˇWw. km[mcWˇmŔˇv ChbnĂmŻXn\m Hcp apPvXlnZns\
AwKoIcnˇp Itb \nŔhmlapĹq.
]ckv]cw FXncmb Bib§Ä Ipdnˇp¶
cp lZokpIÄ ImWpI. \_n (kz) ]dbp¶p: ""enwKw kv]Ŕin¨hł hpfqAv FSpˇWw''.
Cu BibsŻ FXnŔ ˇp¶ asämcp lZokv C{]ImcamWv. ""enwKw kv]Ŕin¨m hpfqAv
apdnbptamsb¶ tNmZyŻn\v, \_n (kz) ]dbp¶p. AXv \nsâ icocŻn s]« Hcp amwk
]nWvV atĂ?''. C§s\bpĹ sshcp˛y§Ä lZokpIfn kw`hnˇptĽmÄ apPvXlnZpI fmWv
Ah ssIImcyw sNtżXv. DZmlcWŻn\v, Camw im^nCu (d) enwK kv] Ŕiw hpfqAv
apdnˇpsa¶v ]dbptĽmÄ, AhŔ KthjWŻn\v Ahew_nˇp¶ "DkzqÂ' (\nZm\imkv{Xw)
ASnŘm\amˇn cmasŻ lZokn\p hniZoIcWw \ÂIWw.
Camw A_q l\o^ (d) enwK
kv]Ŕiw hpfqAv apdnˇnsöv ]dbptĽmÄ H¶mw lZokn\v Ahcpw thsd hymJym\w
IsŻWw. \n_Ô\sbmŻ apPvXlnZn\v am{Xw km[yamIp¶ ImcyamWnXv. HcSnŘm\
hnjbw ChnsS {]tXyIambn HmŔŻn cnˇWw. JpŔB\nepw ]Żp eŁŻnÂ]cw
lZokpIfnepamWv Hcp apPvXlnZnsâ KthjWw \StˇXv. Chbn JpŔB\pw Hcp eŁŻnÂ
Xmsg lZokpIfpamWv \˝psS ssIhiapĹXv. e`yamb lZokpIÄ Xs¶ ]qŔ®ambn
kzlolmbn Řnc s¸«XpaĂ. Ahtijnˇp¶ HĽXv eŁw lZokpIÄ IqSn am\ZWvVamˇnbmWv
CamapIÄ KthjWw \SŻnbn«pĹXv. Ch amän \nŔŻnbpĹ CPvXnlmZv A]qŔ®
ambncnˇpsa¶Xn ktµltabnĂ.
B[p\nI temIw A`napJoIcnˇp¶
FĂm {]i\§ÄˇpapĹ {]Xnhn[ IŔ˝ im kv{X {K٧fn e`nˇpw. Ah IsŻm\pĹ Ignhv
\mw t\SnsbSpˇWw.
AĂmlp ]dbp¶p: ""`btam \nŔ`btam
Dmˇp¶ Hcp Imcyw kwPmXambm AhŔ AXv sIm«ntLmjnˇp¶p. dkqenteˇpw
DepÂAwdn (apPvXlnZpIÄ) teˇpw AXns\ AhŔ hn«p sImSpŻncps¶¦n KthjW ]mShapĹ
AhŔ AXns\ kw_Ôn¨v Adnbpambncp¶p''(\nkmAv 83).
Cu kqŕŻnsâ hniZocWŻn Camw
dmkn(d) FgpXp¶p: ""{]kvXpX kmlNcy Żn \nŔ®mbI hn[n Adnbmł Ahsc
kao]nˇWsa¶mWv AĂmlp \njvIŔin ˇp¶Xv. JpŔB\nepw lZoknepw AXnsâ hn[n
hyŕamImŻXmWnXn\v ImcWw. AXsæn CkvXnĽmXzn (KthjWw) \v Řm\anĂtĂm. AXv
sImv Xs¶ Cu kmlNcyŻn CkvXnĽmXzv (KthjWw) tcJbmsW¶pw AXn\p Ignbp¶hsc
km[mWˇmŔ A\pIcnˇÂ \nŔ_ÔamsW¶pw Cu kqŕw sXfnbnˇp¶pv'' (dmkn 10:200).
JpŔBł ]dbp¶p: ""kXy
hnizmknItf, AĂmlphn\pw dkqen\pw Dep Awdn\pw \n§Ä hgns¸SpI''(\nkmAv
59).
kqŕŻn ]dŞ DepÂAwdv sImv hnhŁ
CPvXnlmZn\v IgnhpĹ ]WvVn X·mcmW¶v X^vkodpXz_cn 2:88epw kp\\p±mcnan
1:40, AÂZpŔdp ałkzqŔ 2:176 epw kzlm_nIfpw Xm_nDIfpamb ]WvVnXsc D˛cn¨v
sImv sXfnbn¨n«pv.
JpŔB\nepw lZoknepw hn[n
hyŕambn ]dŞhbnemWv JpŔBs\bpw kp¶Żn s\bpw A\pkcnˇmł AĂmlp ]dŞXv. JpŔB\nepw
kp¶Żnepw hn[n hyŕam ˇmŻ Imcy§Ä kw_Ôn¨v JpŔB\nepw kp¶Żnepw KthjWw \SŻn
hn[n IstŻXn\m AXn\v IgnhpĹ DepÂAwdns\ A\pkcnˇpI Xs¶ thWw. hn[n
IsŻmł apPvXlnZv \SŻp¶ Hcp kmlknI {]{InbbmWv Jnbmkv. |