apkvenw temIw AwKoIcn¨
JWvVnXamb tcJbmWv CPvamAv. \kvJn\p(1)t]mepw CXp hnt[baÃ. CPvamAv sImv
Øncs¸« Hcp hnjb¯n\p Hcn¡epw \nba {]m _eyw \jvSamInÃ. CPvamAv Zo\nÂ
sXfnhmsW¶v Ipdn¡p¶ Bb¯ns\ kw_ Ôn¨v Camw im^nCu (d) tbmSv tNmZn¡s¸«t¸mÄ
ap¶qdv {]mhiyw JpÀB³ ]mcm bWw sNbvX tijw \nkmAv kqd¯nse Bb¯mWv F¯n¨Xv
(dmkn, hmfyw 13, t]Pv 43).
""k·mÀKw hyàamb tijw Bsc¦nepw
{]hmNIÀ¡v FXncmhpIbpw apAvan\pIÄ kzoIcn¨XÃm¯ amÀKw ]n´pScpIbpw sNbvXmÂ
Aht\säSp¯Xnsâ `mcw Ah s\¯s¶ \mw G¸n¡pw. Ahs\ \mw \cK¯nte¡p tNÀ¡pw.
AXp sN¶ptN cp¶ Øe§fn sh¨v Gähpw No¯bmIp¶p'' F¶ BibapÄs¡mÅp¶XmWv
D]cypà kqàw.
apAvan\pIfptSXÃm¯ amÀKw
kzoIcn¡p¶Xnsâ `hnjy¯pIÄ Cu kqàw hyà am¡p¶p. Hcp hnjb¯nepÅ CPvamAv
kXyhnizmknIfpsS amÀKambXn\m AXp AhKWn¡Â asämcp amÀKt¯mSp
XpScembncn¡pw. AXp h³ Ipä§fn s]Spsa¶v ssiJv lk\p AYzmÀ (d) lminbXp
PwCÂ PhmanAv hmfyw 2, t]Pv 233 Â hyàam¡nbncn¡p¶p.
tIhew apAvan\pIfpsS am{Xw
GtIm]\aà CPvamAv. {]XyqX Cuam\nI amb ]qÀ®Xbpw AKm[amb ]mWvVnXyhpw
KthjW ]SpXzhapÅ ]WvVn X·mcpsS GtIm]\amWXv.
Camw kp_vIn (d) CPvamCs\
C{]Imcw \nÀÆNn¨ncn¡p¶p. ""\_n (kz) bpsS h^m Xn\p tijw GsX¦nepw
hnjb¯n Hcp Ime¯pÅ KthjW ]SpXz apÅ ]¬ VnX·mÀ apgph³ GtIm]n¡pI''.
CPvamAv apPvXlnZpIsf sImv am{Xw {]tXy IamWv. aäpÅhcpsS GtIm]\¯n\p Hcp
{]kànbpanÃ. CXp AhnXÀ¡nXas{X (PwDÂ PhmanAv hmfyw 2, t]Pv 176, 177).
JpÀB³, kp¶¯v, CPvamAv F¶nhsb
Xpey {]m[m\yt¯msSbmWv JpÀB³ Xs¶ ]cnNbs¸Sp¯p¶Xv. AÃmlp ]dbp¶p :""AÃmlphn\pw
dkqen\pw Dep Awdn\pw \n§Ä hgns¸SpI'' (kqd¯p¶nkmAv) Camw dmkn(d) Cu
Bb¯ns\ hniZoIcn¡p¶Xp ImWpI.
""Cu Bb¯n AÃmlphn\pw dkqen\pw
hgns¸Sm³ ]dªXnt\msSm¸amWv DepÂAwdn\pw hgns¸Sm³ AÃmlp Ie¸n¨Xv. At¸mÄ
AÃmlphns\bpw dkqens\bpw t]mse¯s¶ sXäp kw`hn¡m¯ hn`mKambncn¡Ww DepÂAwdv.
ImcWw sXäv kw`hn¡p¶hÀ¡v hgns¸Sm³ AÃmlp Xd¸n¨v ]dbnÃ. AÃmlphn\pw dkqen\pw
hgns¸SWsa¶v IÂ]n¨ AtX ssienbnemWv Dep Awdn\p hgns¸Sm\pw ]dbp¶Xv. AXn\mÂ
DepÂAwdv sXäv kw`hn¡m¯hcm sW¶v XoÀ¨. A¼nbm¡Ä¡pÅ Cu khntijXbpÅhÀ Hcp \nÝnX
kaqlam IWw. Ahcs{X Alvep lÃn h AJvZv (apPvXlnZpIÄ). At¸mÄ AÃmlphn
sâbpw dkqensâbpw hm¡pIÄ tcJbmIp¶ {]Imcw apPvXlnIpfmIp¶ kaql ¯nsâ
A`n{]mbhpw tcJbmsW¶v Øncs¸«p ( X^vkodpÀ dmkn: hmfyw 10, t]Pv 144).
JpÀB³ kp¶¯pt]msebpÅ Hcp
tcJbmbn KWn¡s¸Sp¶Xv AhcpsS GtIm]\w am{XamWv. Häs¸« A`n{]mb§fÃ, Camw
dmkn (d) ]dbp¶p: ""ta Bb¯n sam¯ hnjb§sf cmbn AÃmlp hn`Pn¨ncn¡p¶p.
(1) hn[n hyàambXv. AhbnÂ
AÃmlphn\pw dkqen\pw DepÂAwdn\pw hgns¸Sm \mWv AÃmlphnsâ \nÀt±iw. (2)
hn[n hyàaÃm¯Xv. Ahbn CPvXnlmZv \S ¯m\mWv \nÀt±iw. AXnte¡pÅ kqN\bmWv
\nkmAv kqd¯nse A¼¯n H¼Xmw Bb¯v (dmkn: hmfyw 10, t]Pv 148).
ta hniZoIcW¯n \n¶v JpÀB³,
kp¶¯v F¶nh t]mse asämcp ASn Øm\ tcJbmWv CPvamAv F¶pw Hcp Imcy¯nÂ
CPvamAv Øncs¸«m ]n¶oSv CPvXnZmln\p Øm\ansöpw hyàambn. CPvamCsâ ]cnKW\obXbmWv
CXp hnfnt¨mXp¶Xv. AXn\memWv Hcp hnjbIambn Øncs¸« CPvamC\p hn]coXw sN¿Â
\njn²amsW¶v Camw kp_vIn(d) PwDÂPhmanC {]kvXmhn¡m³ ImcWw. JpÀB³ kqà¯nÂ
hyàamb Xm¡oXv h¶Xn\m ewL\w h³ Ipä ¯n s]Spsa¶v lminbXp AXzmÀ: hmfyw
2, t]Pv 233 Â hyàam¡nbn«pv.
C{]Imcw GIIWvTamb {]kvXmh\ ]WvVnX·mÀ
\S¯Wsa¦n Bhiyamb tcJ e`n¨ncn¡Ww. {]kvXpX tcJ \ap¡v e`n¨nsöXp
apPvXlnZpIfpsS CPvamCs\ _m[n¡pIbnÃ. hmkvXh¯n Cu hnjbIambn CPvamAv Xs¶
{]k àam¡p¶Xv XÂ kw_Ôamb tcJ \ap¡ e`n¡mXncn¡pt¼mgmWv.
aZvl_nsâ ]WvVnXscÃmw CXp ]dªn«pv.
im^nCu \nZm\ imkv{X {KÙamb PwDÂPhmanAv hmfyw 2, t]Pv 195, l\^o \nZm\
imkv{X {KÙamb ^hmXnlpÀd lvaq¯v hmfyw 2, t]Pv 239, amenIo \nZm\
imkv{Xamb ap³Xl Aa hmfyw 1, t]Pv 43 F¶nh t\m¡pI.
CXpsImmWv \nivNnXamb Hcp
lZokns\ kw_Ôn¨v AXp \kvJv sN¿s¸«Xm sW¶pw, \kvJnt·Â Adnbn¡p¶ sXfnhv
CPvamBsW¶pw lm^nfv hen¿p CdmJn (d) ^Xvlp apKokv t]Pv 322  {]kvXmhn¨Xv.
idC¿mb e£y¯nsâ ]n³_eanÃmsX
Hcp hnjb¯n apPvXlnZpIfpsS CPv amAv kw`hn¡nÃ. sXfnhnsâ A`mh¯nepÅ GtIm]\w
sXämb Imcy¯nt·epÅ GtIm]\amWv. CXp kw`hyasöv \_n (kz) ]dªXmbn lm^nfv
A_q\psFw (d) lnÂbXv hmfyw 3, t]Pv 33 epw C_v\p Aºmkv (d) hgn
XnÀapZnbpw ss_lJn (d) bpw \nthZ\w sNbvXXmbn A ZpÀdp a³kzqÀ hmfyw 2,
t]Pv 222 epw A_p\fvdXv (d) hgn Camw AlvaZv (d) \nthZ\w sNbvXXmbn
aPvaDÊhmCZv hmfyw 1, t]Pv 177 epw ImWmhp¶XmWv. A_q\fvdXn (d) Â \n¶v Cu
lZokv Camw Xz_vdm\n (d) bpw C_v\p apÀZqb (d) bpw \nthZ\w sNbvXXmbn AÂZpÀdpÂ
a³kzqÀ hmfyw 3, t]Pv 18 epw D²cn¨n«pv.
(1)\nehnepÅ \nabs¯ FSp¯pIfbp¶Xn\mWv
\kvJv F¶p ]dbpI. CXv AÃm lphn \n¶v \_n (kz) aptJ\ e`n¡p¶ hnjbamWv.
BcpsSbpw hntcm[¯n\v Cu hnjb¯n {]kànbnÃ. \kvJv \S¶Xmbn Adnbm\pÅ Hcp
amÀKamWv CPv amAv. Camw im^nCu (d) bpw C¡mcyw AwKoIcn¨n«pv. Camw im^nCu
(d) ]d bp¶p: ""acWw Bk¶amb tcmKn Xsâ AhIminIÄ¡v kz¯nsâ \nÝnX hn lnXw
hkzn¿¯mbn \ÂIWsa¶mWv JpÀBsâ IÂ]\. A\´cmhIminI Ä¡v hkzn¿¯nsö lZokv apl±nkpIÄ
(lZokv ]WvVnX·mÀ) kzoIcn¡p ¶nÃ. ]t£, {]kvXpX lZoknsâ Bibw kÀÆ ]¬VnX·mcpw
GtIm]n¨Xmb Xn\m JpÀB³ ]dª hkzn¿¯v \nbaw A{]m_eyam¡s¸« \nbaam sW¶v ]¬VnX·mÀ
{]kvXmhn¨p (^Xvlp apÂlow hmfyw 1, t]Pv 58).
Camw KÊmen (d) FgpXp¶p: "Hcp
hnjb¯n KthjWw \S¯p¶ apPvXlnZv, X hnjbIambn CPvamAv Dtm F¶mWv
BZyambn Nn´nt¡Xv. CPvamAv Ds¶v kvYncs¸«m InXm_nepw kp¶¯nepapÅ ]cntim[\
Dt]£nt¡ XmWv. ImcWw Ah cpw \kvJn\p hnt[bamWv. CPvamAv \kvJn\p
hnt[baÃ. BbXn\m InXm_nepw kp¶¯nepw DÅXn\v hncp²ambn CPvamAv Øncs¸«mÂ
\kvJv \S¶n«ps¶Xn\p AXpXs¶ JWvVnXamb sXfnhmWv''(AÂ apkvX kzv^ hmfyw 2,
t]Pv 392).
Npcp¡¯nÂ, CPvamAv CÃm¯t¸mgmWv
kp¶¯nte¡v aSt§sX¶p hcp t¼mÄ kp¶¯nt\¡mÄ ap³KW\bpÅ tcJbmWv CPvamAv F¶p
hcp¶p. At¸mÄ AhcpsS GtIm]\w (CPvamAv) Øncs¸«m ]ns¶ AXns\Xncn kp ¶¯v
Is¯nbm Xs¶bpw AXp tcJbmbn Ahew_n¡m¯Xpw CPvamAv Ahew_nt¡XpamWv. {]kvXpX
lZokpw AXnsâ hymJym\hpw Is¯nb apPvXlnZpIfmWtÃm AXns\Xncn GtIm]n¡p¶Xv.
CXpXs¶bmWv Dkzq {KÙ§fn CPvamAv \Êzns\¡mÄ ap´n¡s¸tSXmsW¶v ]dªXnsâ
clkyw (CwDÂ PhmanAv hmfyw 2, t]Pv 372 t\m¡pI).
|