D¯cw:
kp¶nIÄ
sN¿p¶ acWm\´c {InbIÄ
]eXpw PamAs¯
Ckveman inÀ¡pw _nZvA¯pamsW¶v
Nn{XoIcn¨v apkvenwIsf X½neSn¸n¡pIbpw
Ip g¸w krjvSn¡pIbpw
sXän¸n¡pIbpw
sNbvXncp¶p. apPo_nsâ D¯cw AwKoIcn¡m³
GsX¦nepw PamAs¯
Ckveman¡mc³
X¿mdmbmÂ
AXp kw_Ôamb ^kmZv
\o§n¡n«nbtÃm.
A{Xbpw kt´mjw.
sshcp²y§fS§nb {]t_m[\¯nse
apPo_nsâ D¯cw \ap¡v
hniIe\w sN¿mw.
D¯c¯nÂ
\n¶pw \ap¡v
a\ÊnemIp¶h
CXmWv.
(1.) A\yÀ¡pthnbÃmsX
Ah\pthn BÀ¡pw
a¿n¯p
\nkvIcn¡m³
km[yaÃ.
(2.) Cu efnXamb
kXyw apkvenbm¡·mÀ¡v
AdnbnÃ.
(3.) a\pjy\v Ah³ {]hÀ¯n¨XÃmsXbnÃ
F¶Xv JpÀB³
kqàamWv. AXns\ FXnÀ¡p¶hÀ
JpÀB\ns\bmWv
FXnÀ¡p¶Xv.(4.)
a¿n¯v \nkvImcw
acn¨hÀ¡p
thn sN¿p¶
]pWyIÀaamIp¶p.
AXv Cu JpÀB³ kqà¯n\v FXncmIp¶p. (5.) Pohn¨ncn¡p¶hÀ¡pw
acn¨hÀ¡pw
thn A\yÀ¡v
{]mÀYn¡mw.
(6.) Pohn¨ncn¡p¶hÀ
acn¨hÀ¡pthn
]pWyIÀ½§Ä
sN¿mw.(7.)
]t£, {]mÀY\ kzoIcn¡p¶Xv
hyànbpsS IÀ½hpw
hnizmkhpw A\pkcn¨mbncn¡pw
(At¸mÄ
acn¨hÀ¡pw
hnizmkhpw IÀ½hpaptm)
(8.) kp¶nIfpw aäpÅhcpw
X½nepÅ
`n ¶m`n{]mbw acn¨
apkvenwIÄ¡v thn
{]mÀYn¡mtam
]pWyIÀ½§Ä
sN¿mtam
F¶o Imcy¯neÃ.
(9.) PamAs¯ Ckveman¡mÀ
kp¶nIfÃ.
(10.) acn¨htcmSv {]mÀYn¡mtam
acn¨hcpsS {]oXn¡pthn
hgn]mSpIÄ BImtam
F¶o Imcy§fnemWv
kp¶nIfpw PamA¯pImcpw X½nepÅ
`n¶X. (11) kp¶nIÄ
sN¿p¶
aäp
Imcy¯nsem¶pw
PamAs¯ Ckveman¡mÀ
`n¶X {]ISn¸n¡pItbm
FXnÀ¡pItbm
CÃ.
(12) acn¨htcmSv {]mÀYn¡epw
AhÀ¡pthn
t\À¨ hgn]mSpIÄ
t\cepw hyàambpw
Ckvemw \ntcm[n¨ Imcy§fmIp¶p.
D¯c¯nsâ BZyhpw Ahkm\hpw
sshcp²yaps¶v GsXmcmÄ¡pw
t_m[yamIpw.
apPo_nsâ hnhc¯nsâ Bghpw ]c¸pw a\ÊnemIpIbpw
sN¿pw. au
ZqZn kmlnXyw am{Xw ]Tn¨h³ sshcp²y§fpw hnhct¡Spw
hnf¼pI
km[mcWamWv. kam[m\n¡mw.
kz´¯n\pthn a¿n¯p
\nkvIcn¡m³
km[yasö
kXyw apkvenbm¡·mÀ
a\Ênem¡nbn«pv.
Cu efnXamb kXyw auZqZnIÄ
AwKoIcn¡mXncn¡m³
\nÀhmlansöpw
apkvenbm¡·mÀ¡v
a\Ênembn«pv.
AXpsImmWtÃm ap
kvenbmÀ tNmZn¨Xv.
]t£, apPo_v tNmZy¯n\v ap¼nÂ
Dcpfp¶Xv ImWm³
Gsd ckapv. ""a\pjy\v Ah³ {]hÀ¯n¨XÃmsXbnÃ
F¶v JpÀB³ kqàaps¶pw
AXns\ FXnÀ¡p¶hÀ
JpÀB\ns\bmWv
FXnÀ¡p¶sX¶pw
]dª apPo_v Xs¶
acn¨hÀ¡v
thn \nkvImchpw
{]mÀY\bpw (Zm\[À½§fpw
aäpw) sN¿msa¶v
]dbp¶p. apPo_nsâ Cu hmZw JpÀB\ns\ FXnÀ¡esÃ?
F¶mÂ
acn¨hÀ¡v
thn sN¿p¶
]pWyIÀ½hpw
{]mÀY\bpw
kzoIcn¡p¶Xv
acn¨hcpsS IÀ½hpw
hnizmkhpa\pkcn¨mbncn¡psa¶mWtÃm
apPo_v ]dbp¶Xv.
F¦n acn¨hÀ¡v
hopw hnizmkhpw
IÀ½hpaptm.
Hcp _lpssZh hnizmkn acn¨ tijw GIssZh hnizmknbmbmÂ
Ahsâ hnizmkw kzoIcn¡¸Sptam?
Ahsâ IÀ½w ^eh¯mIptam?
]mÀ«n Hm^oknÂ
Xe ]Wbw sh¨ auZqZnIfÃmsX
CXv AwKoIcn¡ptam?
apkvenw temI¯n\v AÚmXamWo
hmZw. acW¯n\v ap¼v AhcpsS hnizmka\pkcn¨mWv Pohn¨ncn¡p¶hcpsS
{]mÀY\bpw ]pWyIÀ½hpw
kzoIcn¡pIsb¶mtWm
apPo_nsâ Dt±iyw. F ¦nÂ
taÂ
JpÀB³ kqà¯n\pt\sc
hn]coXasà Cu
hmZw. JpÀBs\ FXn
À¡p¶XnÂ
apPo_pw {]XnbsÃ?
acWs¸«hÀ¡pthn
]pWyIÀ½w sNbvXmÂ
AXv acWs¸«hÀ¡v
^ew sN ¿ptam?
F¶v BZyw \ap¡v
]cntim[n¡mw.
tijw taÂ
kqàs¯ kw_Ôn¨v
Nn´n¡mw.
Camw _pJmcn(d)bpw apkvenapw(d) dnt¸mÀ«psNbvX
Hcp lZokn \n¶v
C§s\ kw{Kln¡mw.
""cv J_dpIfpsS
AcnIneqsS \_n(kz) X§Ä
\S¶pt]mbn. P\§fpsS
CSbn \nÊmcambXpw
F¶m AÃmlphnsâ
ASp¡Â alm]m]hpamb
Imcy§Ä¡pthn
Cu cv J_dmfnIfpw in£n¡s¸Sp¶pv. HcmÄ
aq{Xs¯ ip²nhcp¯p¶XnÂ
kq£vaX ]men¡m¯h\pw
A]c³ GjWn¡mc\pambncp¶p
F¶v \_n(kz) ]dªp.
A\´cw Hcp Cu¯¸\
a«Â FSp¯v cv `mKam¡n
Hcp `mKw Hcp J_dnsâ
taenepw atäXv
ASp¯ J_dnsâ
apIfnepw Ip¯n. Ch DW§mXncn¡p¶
Imet¯mfw ChcpsS
in£¡v Cfhv e`n¡p”sa¶v
\_n(kz) ]dbpIbpw sNbvXp. DW§m¯ Cu¯¸\ a«Â
Xkv_olv sNmÃp¶
ImcW¯mÂ
AXv apIfnÂsh¨
J_dmfnIÄ¡v
Bizmkhpw in£bnÂ
Cfhpw e`n¡psa¶mWv
\_n(kz) ]dbp¶Xv. tIhew Hcp Cu¯¸\ a«ensâ Xkv_olv ImcWw in£
eLqIcn¡s¸Sp¶psh¦nÂ
apkvenamb a\pjy³
J_dn\cnIn sh¨v sN¿p¶
JpÀB³ ]mcmbWw
XpS§nb k¡À½§Ä
hgn acWs¸«hÀ ¡v
kpJhpw kt´mjhpw
e`n¡psa¶v
]dtbXnÃtÃm.
Cu lZokv
hniZoIcn¨psImv AÃmam
sF\n(d) Camw
JXzm_n(d)bn \n¶pw D²cn¡p¶p.
""J_dnsâ ASp¯v sh¨v JpÀB³ ]mcmbWw sN¿p¶Xv
kp¶¯msW¶Xn\v Cu lZoknÂ
sXfnhpv. Hcp
ac¯nsâ Xkv_olv sImv Xs¶ KpWw {]Xo£n¡msa¦nÂ
JpÀB³ HmXp¶Xv
sImv ^ehpw A\p{Klhpw Gsd {]Xo£n¡matÃm''
(DwZXpÂ
Jmcn 3/118, iÀlp
apkvenw 1/141).
apÃm
Aen¿pÂ
Jmcn(d) ]dbp¶p:
""J_dnS¯n sh¨v
JpÀB³ HmXÂ
kp¶¯msW¶v CXnsâ
ASnØm\¯nÂ
]WvVnX·mÀ
hyàam¡nbn«pv.
Hcp Cu ¯¸\ a«ensâ Xkv_olns\¡mÄ
D¯aamWtÃm
JpÀB³ ]mcmbWw F¶XmWv
\ymbw'' (anÀJmXv
1/286).
lZoknÂ
C¡mcyw
hyàambn ]cmaÀin¨Xmbn
ImWmw. ss_lJn(d) \nthZ\w sNbvX lZoknÂ
C§s\bpv. ""\_n(kz)
]dªp:
Hcp hyàn J_dn\Sp¯v kqd¯v bmko³ HmXnbmÂ
B J_dmfnIÄ¡v
in£ Cfhv sN¿s¸Sp¶Xpw
AhbpsS F®¯n\v Ah\v KpWw e`n¡p¶XpamWv''
(anÀJmXv 2/382).
A_vZpÃmln_v\p
Dadn(d) \n¶v \nthZ\w:""\n§Ä
Bsc¦nepw acn¨mÂ
A hs\
Xmakn¸n¡cpXv. DSs\ adhpsN¿Ww. Ahsâ XebpsS `mK¯v AÂ_JdbpsS
BZy`mKhpw ImÂ`mK¯v
Ahkm\ `mKhpw ]mcmbWw sN¿Ww. F¶v \_n(kz) ]dªXmbn Rm³ tI«p'' (ss_lJn).
aäv
]pWyIÀ½§Ä
sNbvXmepw acWs¸«h\v
^ew sN¿psa¶v
Ckvemw ]Tn¸n¡p¶p.
acWs¸«hcpsS KpW¯n\pthn Zm\[À½w
sN¿Â {]tXyIw kp¶¯mWv.
acWt¯mSv sXm«Sp¯ Znhk§fnÂ
{]tXyIambn [À½w
sN¿Ww. Camw
AlvaZpw(d), A_q\psFapw(d) dnt¸mÀ«psN¿p¶p.
acWs¸«hÀ¡v BZy
s¯ Ggp Znhkw {]tXyI ]co£Ww DmIpw. AXpImcWw B Znhk§fnÂ
A¶Zm\w \S¯p¶Xv
kzlm_nIÄ Ncybm¡nbncn¡p¶p.
acWs¸«hÀ¡v th
n Pohn¨ncn¡p¶hÀ
sN¿p¶
lÖv,
kzZJ XpS§nb k¡À½§Ä
^ew sN¿psa¶Xn\v
sXfnhpIÄ \nch[nbpv.
Nn´n¡p¶hÀ¡v
CXv Xs¶ [mcmfatÃm.
acWs¸«hÀ¡v
thnbpÅ
k¡À½§Ä
^ew sN¿p¶Xn\v
a¿n¯v \nkvIm
cw Xs¶ sXfnhmWtÃm.
CXv k½Xn¨ HcmÄ¡v
asämcp
k¡À½hpw
\ntj[n¡pI km[yaÃ.
AXpsImmWv
auZqZn apPo_v t]mepw ]pWyIÀ½§Ä
^ew sN¿psa¶v
]dbp¶Xv.
acn¨ GgpZnhkw XpSÀ¨bmbn
kzlm_nIÄ ASnb´ncw
Ign¨ncp¶psh¶v ta lZokv sImv sXfnªXmWtÃm.
kp¶nIfDw
auZqZnIfpw X½n ZnIvdv sNm ÃÂ,
J¯¸pc sI«Â
(J_dnsâbSp¯v
HmXÂ), `£Ww [À½w
sN¿Â,
ASnb´ncw Ign¡Â
XpS§nb Imcy§fnÂ
`n¶m`n{]mbansöv
apPo_v hyàam¡nbncns¡
IqSpXÂ
sXfnhpIfnte¡v
IS¡p¶nÃ.
F¶mÂ
a\pjy\v Ah³ {]hÀ¯n¨XÃmsXbnsö
JpÀB³ kqàs¯ ]Wv
VnX·mÀ hymJym\n¨ncn¡pIbmWv.
Camw sF\n(d) ]dbp¶p: ""CXp kw_Ôambn ]WvVnX·mÀ F«v A`n{]mb¡mcmWv.
H¶v. B kqàw a³kqJv (\nba{]m_eyanÃm¯Xv)
BIp¶p. C_v\pAºmkn(d)sâ
A`n{]mbamWnXv. cv. C{_mlnw \_n(A), aqkm \_n(A) F¶o cv
A¼nbm¡fpsS P\Xsb sImv {]tXyIamWv B \nbaw. F¶mÂ
\½psS Cu D½¯n\v
AhÀ sNbv
XXpw AhÀ¡pthn
aäpÅhÀ
sNbvXXpw D]Icn¡pw.
CIvcna(d)bpsS
A`n{]mbamWnXv. aq¶v, kqà¯nÂ
]dª
a\pjy³ sImv hnh£
Im^nÀ (Ahnizmkn)
BIp¶p. d_oD_v\p A\kn(d)sâ A`n{]mbamWnXv. (CX\pkcn¨v kqà¯nsâ
AÀYan{]ImcamWv. Im^ndmb a\pjy\v Ahsâ AaeÃmsX
^es¸SnÃ.
Ah\msW¦nÂ
AaÂ
CÃXm\pw) \mev.
AÃmlphnsâ \oXnbpsS
XmXv]cya\pkcn¨v a\pjy³ {]hÀ¯n¨Xv
am{Xta Ah\v ^es¸SpIbpÅq.
F¶mÂ
aäpÅhÀ
{]hÀ¯n¨Xv
^es¸Sp¶Xv \oXnbpsS XmXv]cya\pkcn¨Ã.
adn¨v AÃmlphnsâ
HuZmcyw sImv am{XamWv. AÃmlp
Dt±in¨{X HuZmcyw
Ah\v sN¿mhp¶XmWtÃm.
lpssk\p_v\p ^fven(d)sâXmWo
A`n{]mbw. A©v. am kB F¶ hm¡n\ÀYw
Ah³ IcpXnbXv F¶mWv. A_q_IvcnÂ
hÀdmJn(d)
tâXmWo A`n{]mbw. (CX\pkcn¨v kqà¯n\ÀYw C{]Imcambn. a\pjy\v Ah³
IcpXnbXÃmsX {]tbmP\s¸SnÃ.)
Bdv, Ahnizmkn¡v
Ah³ sNbvX \ÂImcy¯n\v
{]Xn^eambn Zp\nbmhn sh¨pÅ
{]Xn^eaÃmsX
asäm¶panÃ.
]mc{XnI PohnX¯nÂ
Ah\Xn \ns¶m¶pw
tijn¡nsöv hnh£.
kAve_n(d)bptSXmWo A`n{]mbw. Ggv, a\pjy\v tISmbn `hn¡p¶Xv
Ah³ sNbvXXÃmsX
asäm¶paÃ.
(HcmÄ
sNbvX Ipä¯n\v
asämcmsf
in£n¡s¸Snsöv
Npcp¡w.)
F«v. a\pjy\v a\pjysâ
{]bXv\aÃmsXbnÃ.
]t£, Imcy§Ä¡pÅ
ImcW§Ä
]eXmbXv sImv
Nnet¸mÄ B {]bXv\w
Ahsâ kz´ambXpw
aäpNnet¸mÄ
ImcWw DmIp¶Xnsâ
hgnbmbXpamIpw. DZmlcWambn Ah sâ aI³ HmXnbXnsâ {]Xn^ew Ah\v
e`n¨Xv B aI³ DmIp¶XnÂ
Ah\v {]bXv\apmbXv
sImmWv. CXpt]mse Xs¶ aäv
Iq«pImc³ Ah\v
thn {]mÀY\ \S¯p¶Xpw
(Ahs\ Iq«pImc\m¡nbXv
Chsâ {]bXv\amWv). AXpt]mse Xs¶ aäpNnet¸mÄ
Zo\nsâ JnZvaXnepw
C_mZXnepambpÅ {]bXv\w.
AXv Zo\nsâ AlvepImcpsS {]oXn¡v
hgnsbmcp¡pw.
C_v\pÊKvhm\n(d)bnÂ
\n¶v A_pÂ^dPv(d)
D²cn¨XmWnX'' (DwZXpÂ
Jmcn 3/119).
Hcp apkvenamb a\pjy³
asämcp acn¨
apkvenamb a\pjy\v
thn JpÀB³ ]mcmbWw sN¿p¶Xv
D]cypà JpÀB³ kqà¯ns\Xncsöv
C{Xbpw hniZoIcn¨XnÂ
\n¶pw hyàambn. F¶ncns¡
Camw im^nCu(d)bpw
A\pbmbnIfpw acn¨hÀ¡v
thn JpÀB³ ]mcmbWw
\S¯n {]Xn^ew AhÀ¡v
lZvb sN¿p¶Xv
^ew kn²n¡p¶nsöv
Cu kqà¯n \n¶v
KthjWw \S¯nbXmbn C_v\pIkoÀ(d) D²cn¨Xv \mw kaÀYn¨Xn\v hncp²aÃ.
ImcWw JpÀB³ ]mcmbWm´cw
{]mÀY\ \S¯mXncp¶Xn\memWv A¸dªsX¶v C_v\pIkodn \n¶v Xs¶ hyàamIpw.
At±lw ]dbp¶p: ""F¶mÂ
{]mÀY\bpw
kzZJbpw a¿n¯nte¡v
{]Xn^ew tNcp¶hbmsW¶Xv
GIIWvTm`n{]mbamWv. \_n(kz)bn \n¶v Xs¶ AXv hyàambn h¶XpamWv''
(X^vkodp C_v\pIkoÀ
4/258).
C_v\plPdn(d)sâ hm¡pIÄ
ImWpI. ""J_dn\cnInÂsh¨v
kuIcyapÅ{X
JpÀB³ ]mcmbWw \S¯nb
tijw {]mÀYn¡Wsa¶ Camwim^nCu(d)bpsS hm¡v
a¿n¯nsâ
ta JpÀB³
]mcmbWw sN¿s¸Snsöv
aäp
]WvVnX·mÀ ]dªXn\v
hncp²asÃsb¶v \o tNmZn¨mÂ
Rm³ adp]Sn ]dbmw.
hncp²aÃ. ImcWw,
acn¨h\v thn shdpw JpÀB³ ]mcmbWw sN¿p¶Xv
kw_Ôn¨mWv
AhÀ ]dªXv.
Camw im^nCu(d) ]dªXmIs« ]mcmbWm\´cw {]mÀY\ \S¯p¶Xv kw_Ôn¨pamWv.
CXv {]Xn^e e_v[nbpÅXv
Xs¶bmWtÃm.
At¸mÄ
FhnsSbmWv
sshcp²yw. F¶Ã,
Camw im^Cu(d)bpsS
{]kn²amb aZvl_v Xs¶ (]mcmbW {]Xn^ew tNcnsöXv, a¿n¯nsâ
km¶n[y¯n sh¨mhmXncn¡pItbm
]mcmbWm\´cw {]mÀYn¡mXncn¡pItbm
sN¿pt¼mgmsW¶
]n ¡me ]WvVnX·mcpsS
hymJym\¯n\v Camw im^nCu(d)bpsS D]cypà hm¡v
Xs¶) iàn \ÂIp¶pv.''
(AÂ ^XmhÂ
Ip_vd 2/27).
Camw \hhn(d) ]dbp¶p: ""acn¨
hyàn¡v Hcp {]Xn^ehpw
tNcnsöv Nne]dªXmbn Camw
amhdZn(d) D²cn¨n«pv. ]t£, CXv _mXznemb aZvl_msW¶pd¸pÅXpw
hyàamb ]nghpw
JpÀB\nsâbpw kp¶¯nsâbpw hyàamb tc J¡pw
apkvenw temI¯nsâ
CPvamC\pw hncp²ambXpamWv. AXpsImpXs¶ AXv ]mtS AhKWn¡s¸tSXpamIp¶p''
(iÀlp apkvenw
1/12þ13). |