D¯cw:
\_n(kz)bpsS Imet¯m D¯a \qämpIfntem tijw ln.
1300 hÀjw ]n¶nSp¶Xv hsctbm A\d_n JpXzp_ temIs¯hnsSbpw \S¡m¯Xpt]mse
JpXzp_¡v ap¼v Hcp Xd{]kwKhpw \S¶n«nÃ. CXpXs¶bmWv im^nCu IÀaim
kv{X ]WvVnX·mÀ JpXzp_ Ad_nbnemIWsa¶Xn\v sXfnhmbn C§s\ ]dªXv. "enam
Pdm Asseln¶mkp' (P\§Ä BNcn¨pt]m¶ Ncy AXmbXn\p thn) ke^pÊzmenlpIfpw
]n³KmanIfpaS§p¶ P\§fmWv hnh£. Nnecp sS hm¡pIfn C§s\ Xs¶
hyàam¡nbn«pv. AhcpsS hm¡pIÄ ImWpI: ""C¯n_mA³ enÊe^n h Je^n'' (ke^pÊzmenlpItfmSpw
tijapÅhtcmSpw A\pIcn¨Xn\pthn) ke^v sImv hnh£ kzlm_m¡fpw Je^v
sImv hnh£ Xm_nDIfpw Xm_nD¯m_nDIfpaS¡apÅ ]n³KmanIfpamsW¶v Camw
iÀJmhn(d) lminbXp¯lvcoÀ 1/267Â hyàam¡nbn«pv.
JpXzp_ km[pX¡v Ad_nbmIÂ
\n_Ô\sbm¶pansöp ]dbp¶ l\^o ] WvVnXÀ Xs¶ A\d_n `mjbn JpXzp_ \nÀhln¡p¶Xv
IpäIcamsW¶v
k½Xn¡p¶p. Ad_nbmIÂ \n_Ô\bmsW¶v
]dbp¶ im^nCu ]WvVnX·mÀ D¶bn¨ tcJ Xs¶bmWv l\^o ]WvVnX·mcpsSbpw
tcJ.
l\^o IÀaimkv{X ]WvVnX\mb
A_vZp l¿n A³kzmcn(d) ]dbp¶p: ""JpXzp_ Ad_nbnemI \n_Ô\sbm¶panÃ.
At¸mÄ ]mÀkn `mj, aäp `mjIÄ XpS§nbh sImv JpXzp_ \nÀhln¨mepw CXv
PmCkmIpw. C{]ImcamWv AhÀ (l\^n IÀaimkv{X ]WvVnXÀ) {]kvXmhn¨n«pÅXv.
F¶m C¸dª PmCkv sImv hnh£ PpapA \nkvImc¯nsâ km[pX At]£n¨v
am{XamWv. (PpapAbpsS \n_Ô\bmb) JpXzp_ F¶ iÀXzv hoSm\pw B JpXzp_
\nÀhln¨psImpÅ PpapA kzlolmIm\pw B JpXzp_ Xs¶ aXn F¶ÀYw. F¶ÃmsX
AXv \ncp]m[nIw A\phZ\obamsW¶ AÀY¯neÃ. ImcWw A\d_n `mjbnepÅ JpXzp_
\_n(kz)bn \n¶pw kzlm_¯n \n¶pw ]c¼cmKX ambn h¶ Ncys¡XncmsW¶XnÂ
ktµlansöv XoÀ¨. At¸mÄ ]ns¶ A§s\ JpXzp_ \nÀhln¡p¶Xv ldmansâ
IpäapÅ Idml¯mIp¶p'' (A³kzmcnbpsS DwZXpÀcnBb ^o lÃn idln hnJmb,
1/200).
asämcp l\^o ]WvVnX\mb
imlv hen¿pÃmlnZlvehn(d) FgpXp¶p: ""JpXzp_ Ad_nbn Xs¶bmIWsa¶v ]dbp¶Xv
temI apkvenwIfpsS \nc´camb Aa A{]Imcambn F¶ ASnØm\¯nemWv'' (Zlvehn(d)bpsS
AÂ apkz^v ^m 1/154).
A_vZp l¿n A³kzmcn(d)
Xs¶ ]dbs«: ""A\d_n JpXzp_ Idml¯msW¶v ]dªXv \nÝbw AXv kp¶¯n\v
hncp²ambXp sImmWv. ImcWw \_n(kz)bpw kzlm_¯pw Ft¸mgpw Ad_nbnÂ
Xs¶bmbncp¶p JpXzp_ \nÀhln¨ncp¶Xv. CXc `mjbn Ahcmsc¦nepw JpXzp_
\nÀhln¨Xmbn CtXhsc D²cn¡s¸«n«nÃ'' (A³kzmcn(d)bpsS BImap¶^mCkv
t]Pv 66).
\_n(kz)bn \n¶pw
kzlm_¯n \n¶pw tijapÅhcn \n¶pw ]c¼cmKXambn h¶Xpw AhÀ \nc´cambn
BNcn¨p t]m¶Xpw Ad_n JpXzp_ BbXpsImv AXn\v hncp²ambn A\d_n JpXp_
\nÀhln¡p¶Xv AhcpsS Ncy¡v FXncpw AhcpsS t\cmb amÀK¯n \n¶v
hyXnNen¡epambXn\m sXäpw IpäIchpamsW¶Xn Ccp aZvl_pIÄ¡nSbnepw
XÀ¡ansöv kw£n]vXw.
F¶m CtX am\ZWvV¯nÂ
thWw JpXzp_¡v ap¼pÅ Xd{]kwKs¯bpw ImWm³. D]cypà ImcW§Ä sImv A\d_n
JpXzp_ A\phZn¨pIqsS¶v a\Ênem¡nb NneÀ Xs¶ akvzel¯nsâ ad]nSn¨v
Xd{]kwK¯n\v A\paXn \ÂInbXv BÝcyw Xs¶. ]t£, JpXzp_ km[pX¡v Ad_n `mj
\n_Ô\bmbXv sImv B \n_Ô\ IqSmsX A\d_n JpXzp_ \nÀhln¡p¶Xv ldmapw
^mknZpamsW¶v im^nCu ]WvVnX·mÀ {]kvXmhn¨Xv t]mse Cu Xd{]kwKw
ldmamsW¶hÀ {]kvXmhn¨nÃ. ImcWw GsXmcp C_mZ¯pw AXnsâ \n_Ô\ IqSmsX
sN¿p¶Xv ^mknZpw ldmapamsW¶v ]WvVnX·mÀ {]kvXmhn¨n«pv'' (Camw C_v\pZJoJn(d)sâ
ClvImap AlvImw 2/10 t\m¡pI). C¸dª \ymbw Xd{]kwK¯nensöv hyàw.
GXmbmepw Cu Xd{]kwKw \_n(kz)bpw
kzlm_¯pw sXm«v ]c¼cmKXambn t]m¶ kp¶¯n\v hncp²amsW¶Xn ktµlanÃ.
F¶ncns¡ CXv kp¶¯v hXvIcn¡p¶Xn\pthn NneÀ \ymbw Is¯pIbmWv.
AXn{]ImcamWv. P\§Ä Adnªncn¡Â Bhiyamb ]e Imcy§fpw Ahsc sXcys¸Sp¯m\pw
t_m[hXvIcn¡m\pw \nkvImctijt¯¡v ]n´n¡p¶ ]£w Npcp¡w
NnebmfpIsfbÃmsX AXn\v In«nÃ. AtXØm\¯v P\§sfÃmw ]Ånbn \ndªv
JpXzp_ XpS§p¶Xn\v ap¼mbn {]kwKw \S¯p¶ ]£w AhscÃmhcpw AXv
{i²n¨ptIÄ¡m³ \nÀ_ÔnXcmIpw. CsXmcp \à ImcyamsW¶Xn kwibanÃtÃm.
hfsc _meniamb \ymbamWnsXt¶mÀ¡pI.
Cu ]dª \ymbw ap³Ime§fnepapmbncp¶p. F¶ncns¡ ap³KmanIfmcpw Cu \·
]cnKWn¨Xmbn ImWp¶nÃ. _lp. C_v\plPÀ(d) ]dbp¶Xv ImWpI. ""FÃm \·sImpw
Gähpw _Ôs¸«hcpw \nkvXpecpambncp¶p kzlm_m¡Ä. F¶ncns¡ Cu D½¯nse Gä
hpw DÂIrjvScpw t{ijvTcpamb kzlm_m¡Ä¡v hne¡s¸« Hcp Imcyw
A{]ImcaÃm¯ Xeapd¡mÀ¡v A\phZn¡s¸Spsa¶v Bsc¦nepw Duln¡p¶ptm?
Hcn¡epw AXnÃ'' (A ^Xmh Ip_vdm 3/161)
AXpsImpXs¶ CXv shdpw [mcW
am{XamWv. Camw \hhn(d)bpsS DkvXmZp IqSnbmb Camw A_qima(d) FgpXp¶p:
""AÃmlphnte¡Sp¡m\pÅ amÀKhpw XzmAXpambn [mcmfamfpIÄ [cn¡p¶
Imcy§fne[nIhpw A§s\bmInÃ.
Nnet¸mÄ AXv sN¿p¶Xnep]cn
Dt]£n¡emIpw A`nImayw. Cu hkvXpX hyàam¡m\mWv Fsâ Cu cN\ Xs¶. \nÝnXamsbmcp
kabt¯m Øet¯m AXsæn Hcp hyàntbmtSm idAv BÚm]n¨ Hcp Imcyw \ncp]m[nIw
\ÃXmsW¶psh¨v ]mac³ AX\pkcn¨v {]hÀ¯n¡pw. bYmÀY¯n Ah\Xv
hnes¸«XmImw. NneXns\ NneXnt\mSv Xpe\w \S¯pIbmWh³. ØeIme
hyXymk§Ä Ah³ a\Ênem¡p¶nÃ. AÃmlphnte¡v ASp¡m\pÅ amÀK§fpw
C_mZ¯pIfpw IqSpXÂ sN¿m\pÅ AXym{KlamWv idAv hne¡nb Øe§fnepw
kab§fnepw B XzmA¯pIÄ sN¿m³ AhÀ¡v {]tNmZIambXv. Chcpw C hsc
t]mepÅhcpw AÃmlp idB¡m¯ Imcy§Ä sImv AÃmlphnte¡Sp¡m³ hn^e{iaw \S¯pIbmWv.
F¶Ã, AÃmlp hne¡nbh sImv. \n§Ä `qanbn \miapm¡cpsX¶v AhtcmSv ]dbs¸«mÂ
\nÝbw R§Ä \· sN ¿p¶hÀ am{XamsW¶mbncn¡pw AhcpsS {]XnIcWw. AdnbpI,
XoÀ¨bmbpw ChÀ Xs¶bmWv \miImcnIÄ. ]t£, AhcXv {Kln¡p¶nÃ'' (Camw
A_qima(d)bpsS InXm_p _mlnkv, t]Pv 25).
Npcp¡¯n P\§sf
t_m[hXvIcn¡epw AhÀ¡mhiyamb Imcy§Ä A hsc ]dªv sXcys¸Sp¯epw tIhew
\ÃXmsW¦nepw ØeþImeþ hyXymkat\y \ÃXmsW¶v ]dªpIqS. PpapA¡pthn P\§Ä
tafn¨ kab¯v Jp Xzp_¡v ap¼mbn AhtcmSv {]kwKw sN¿p¶Xv ]c¼cmKXamb
Ncys¡XncmbXn\p ]pdsa PpapAbpsS {]tXyIamb kp¶¯pIÄ¡v AXv hnLmXw
krjvSn¡p¶Xpw AXpsImpXs¶ B {]kwKw {ihn¡Â sImv {]kvXpX kp¶¯pIfpt]£n¡m³
AhÀ hnt[bcmhpIbpw sN¿p¶p.
JpXzp_¡v ap¼mbn
PpapAs¡¯p¶hÀ ]ment¡ kp¶¯pIÄ IÀaimkv{X ]WvVnX·mÀ hnhcn¡p¶pv.
Camw dm^nCu(d) idlp I_oÀ 4/623, 624  ] dbp¶p. ""JpXzp_¡v
ap¼mbn lmPcpÅhÀ ZnIvdv sImpw JpÀB³ HmXÂ sImpw \_n(kz)bpsS taÂ
kzem¯v sNmÃÂ sImpw tPmenbmIWw. sh ÅnbmgvN cmhnepw ]Ienepw \_n(kz)bpsS
ta kzem¯v hÀ±n¸n¡pI, kqdXp Ilv^v HmXpI XpS§nbh kp¶¯mb
Imcy§fmIp¶p.''
Camw \hhn(d) ]dbp¶p: ""JpXzp_bpsS
ap¼v lmPcmIp¶hÀ ZnIvdv, JpÀB³ ]mcmbWw, kzemXv F¶nhsImv
tPmenbmI kp¶¯mIp¶p'' (idlp apl±_v, 4/548). C{]Imcw Xs¶ duf
1/551 epw ImWmw).
JpXzp_bpsS ap¼v D]cypà
{]kwKw \S¯p¶Xpw AXv {ihn¡p¶Xpw B kab¯v P\§Ä¡v kp¶¯mb Imcy§Ä
sImv tPmenbmIp¶Xn\v XSÊw krjvSn¡psa¶v ]dtbXnÃ. shÅnbmgvN Znhkw
\_n(kz)bpsS an¼dn\cnIn sh¨v i_vZn¨htcmSv \n§Ä ChnsSsh¨v
i_vZn¡cpsX¶pw PpapA \nkv Imcm\´cw \_n(kz)sb kao]n¨v \n§fpsS
A`n{]mbm´c§fn Rm³ XoÀ¸v I¸n¡msa¶pw DaÀ(d) ]dªXmbn \pAvam\p_v\p
_iodn(d) \n¶v Camw apkvenw(d) D²cn¡p¶ lZoknsâ hymJym\¯n Camw \hhn(d)
FgpXp¶Xv ImWpI: ""shÅnbmgvN ZnhkamsW¦nepw Asænepw ]ÅnbnÂ
i_vZapbÀ¯p¶Xv Idml¯msW¶Xn\pw \nkvImc¯n\pthn P\§Ä tafn¨ kab¯v
CÂav sImtm atäm i_vZapbÀ¯n¡qsS¶Xn\pw Cu lZokn tcJbpv. \nkvImc¯nÂ
tafn¨hÀ¡pw ZnIvdpw kzem¯pw sNmÃns¡mncn ¡p¶hÀ¡pw AXv ieyamIpsa¶Xv
Xs¶ ImcWw'' (idlpapkvenw 13/277).
Cu lZoknsâ ASnØm\¯nÂ
Camwdmkn(d) FgpXp¶p: ""shÅnbmgvN Znhkw \nkvImc¯n\v ap¼v hnÚm\
NÀ¨¡v thn kZÊv kwLSn¸n¡p¶Xpw h«an«v Ccn¡p¶Xpw Idml¯msW¶v \mw
D²cn¨ lZokv Adnbn¡p¶pv. ZnIvdv, kz em¯v F¶nh sImv
tPmenbmhpIbpw ]n¶oSv JpXzp_ {ihn¡pIbpamWv Ah³ thXv. \nkvImcm\´cw
kZÊv kwLSn¸n¡p¶Xnepw h«an«v Ccn¡p¶Xnepw ]´ntIsSm¶panÃ'' (X^vkodpÂ
dmkn 4/15).
J¯zm_n(d)bpsS hm¡pIÄ
ImWpI: ""hnÚm\¯n\pw NÀ¨¡pw \nkvImc¯n\v ap¼v thZn kwLSn¸n¡p¶Xv
Idml¯mWv. B kab¯v kzemXv sImv tPmenbmIm\pw tijw JpXzp_ {ihn¡m\pamWv
Aht\mSpÅ BÚ. \nkvImcm\´cw kwLSn¡epw h«an«v Ccn¡epw A\phZ\obamWv''
(Camw kpbqYn(d)bpsS idlpÃpwA, t]Pv 52).
asämcp im^nCu ]WvVnX\mb
Camw _Kvhn(d) idlpÊp¶bn FgpXnbXv ImWpI: ""hnÚm\ NÀ¨¡v thn \nkvImc¯n\v
ap¼v shÅnbmgvN kZÊv kw LSn¸n¡p¶Xv Idml¯msW¶v lZokn h¶n«pv.
kzem¯v, ZnIvdv F¶nh sImv tPmenbmhpI, tijw JpXzp_ {ihn¡pI
XpS§nbhbmWv sNt¿Xv. \nkvImctijw CXn ]´ntIsSm¶panÃ'' (anÀJmXv
1/468).
im^nCu aZvl_nse {][m\ ]WvVnX\mb
Camw kÀIin(d) FgpXp¶p: ""\nkv Imc¯n\v ap¼v hnÚm\ kZÊv kwLSn¸n¡p¶Xv
\nÝbw Idml¯mIp¶p. kzem¯v sImv tPmenbmIm\pw tijw JpXzp_ {ihn¡m\pamWv
BÚm]n¡s¸«n«pÅXv'' (kÀJinbpsS CAvemapÊmPnZv _n AlvIman akmPnZv,
t]Pv 328, 329).
IÀaimkv{X {KÙ§Ä am{Xta
X§Ä tcJbmbn kzoIcn¡pIbpÅqsh¶v iTn¡p¶hÀ¡v CAvemapÊmPnZv
Xncn¨SnbmWv. ImcWw AXv im^nCu aZvl_nse {][m\ IÀaimkv{X {KÙamWv.
am{XaÃ, IÀaimkv{X ]WvVnX³ ]dªmepw aXnbmInÃ. IÀaimkv{X {KÙ§fnÂ
Xs¶ ]dsª¦nte tcJbmbn KWn¡mhq F¶ hmZ¯n\v IÀaimkv{X {KÙ§fn \n¶v
hà tcJbpw D²cn¡m\mInÃ. GXmbmepw IÀaimkv{X {KÙ§fpw AÃm¯hbpw
D]cypà Xd{]kwK¯n\v Iq«p\n¡p¶nÃ.
shÅnbmgvN Znhkw A[ym]\w
ths¶v sh¨Xnsâ clkysa´msW¶ tNm Zy¯n\v adp]Snbmbn C_v\plPÀ(d) ]dbp¶Xv
ImWpI: ""shÅnbmgvN Znhkw apAvan\pIfpsS BtLmj ZnhkamsW¶v lZoknÂ
h¶n«pv. A¶v Ah sIm v tPmenbmIÂ A\ptbmPyaÃ. CXmWv A¶v A[ym]\hpw
aäpw ths¶v sh¨Xnsâ clkyw'' (AÂ^Xmh Ip_vd, 1/236).
F¶m Camw KÊmen(d)
ClvbmCÂ ]dª Hcp hm¡mWv Cu {]kwKhmZnIÄ tcJbm¡p¶Xv. IÀaimkv{X {KÙ§fnÂ
h¶tX kzoIcn¡q F¶v ]dbp¶hÀ Clvbm IÀaimkv{X {KÙasöv HmÀt¡XmWv.
ClvbmCsâ hm¡pIÄ C{]ImcamWv: ""shÅnbmgvN Znhkw \nkvImc¯nsâ ap¼v
lÂJ kwLSn¸n¡p¶Xv \_n(kz) hntcm[n¨Xv sImv B lÂJbn lmPcmI A\ptbmPyaÃ.
]t£, lÂJ kwLSn¸n¨h³ AÃmlphns\ sImpw Ahsâ hn[nhne¡pIÄ sImpw Úm\nbmhpIbpw
AÃmlphnsâ Zo³ kw_Ôn¨v shÅnbmgvN cmhnse ]Ånbn sh¨v DXvt_m[\w \S¯pIbpw
sN¿p¶psh¦n B kZÊn ]s¦Sp¡mhp¶XmWv.''
ClvbmCsâ hm¡pIÄ
apgps¡bpw ]cntim[n¡p¶ ]£w ClvbmAv C¡q« À¡v Iq«p\n¡p¶nsöv
hyàamIpw. shÅnbmgvN ]peÀ¨tbm PpapA \nkv Imc tijtam hnÚm\ kZÊpIÄ
kwLSn¸n¡p¶psh¦n AXn kw_Ôn¡mhp¶XmWv. CXv ]dª tijamWv ClvbmCsâ
D]cypà hm¡pIÄ. XpSÀ ¶pÅ hm¡pIÄ IqSn ImWpI:
""AÃmlphnsâ Zo³ Imcy§sf
Ipdn¨v shÅnbmgvN cmhnse DXvt_m[\w \S¯p¶hsâ kZÊn ]s¦Sp¯m ]peÀs¨
]pds¸SpI, hnÚm\§Ä {ihn¡pI, F¶o cv kp¶¯pIÄ Ah\v ka\zbn¸n¡m\mIpw''
(ClvbmCsâ hym Jym\ {KÙamb CXvlm^v, 3/373).
Npcp¡¯n shÅnbmgvN
PpapA \nkvImc¯nsâ ap¼v Clvbm ]dª hnÚm \ kZÊv shÅnbmgvN ]peÀs¨
kwLSn¸n¡p¶Xv kw_Ôn¨v am{XamWv. C¶v NneÀ \S¯p¶ t]mse PpapA
kabt¯mSSp¯mbn _m¦n\v apt¼m ]nt¼m \S¯p¶Xv kw_Ôn¨Ã. PpapA¡v thn ]peÀs¨
]pds¸SpI, hnÚm\w {ihn¡pI F¶o cv kp¶¯pI Ah\v ka\zbn¸n¡m\mIpsa¶
]cmaÀiw Xs¶ CXn\v hyàamb sXfnhmWv.
A_qZmhqZnsâ hymJym\amb
_Zvep aPvlqZv 6/769, 770 FgpXp¶p: ""\nkvImc¯n\v ap¼v kZÊv
kwLSn¸n¡p¶Xv hntcm[n¡s¸SWsa¶v ]dªXv kqcy³ a[y¯n \n¶v sXäp¶Xnt\mSSp¯
kab¯mWv. {]XypX shÅnbmgvN ]peÀ s¨bmsW¦n hnÚm\¯n\v thnbpw aäp
Zo\o Imcy§Ä¡pthnbpw kZÊv kwLSn¸n¡mhp¶XmWv.''
l\^o IÀaimkv{X {KÙamb
BImap¶^mCkv t]Pv 67Â FgpXp¶p: ""(kv{XoIÄ s]cp¶mÄ \nkvImc¯n\v ]s¦Sp¯ncp¶
Ime¯v) AhÀ kZÊn \n¶IsebmbXpsImv JpXzp_ {ihn¨pImWnsöpsh¨v AXp
Ignªtijw \_n (kz) AhcpsS AcnIn sN¶v AhÀ¡v kz´ambn D]tZiw \S¯nsb¶v
lZokn h¶n«pv. F¶m A\d_nIÄ ]s¦Sp¯ PpapAbn AhÀ JpXzp_ {ihn¨v
ImWnsöpsh¨v AhcpsS `mjbn AhÀ¡pthn DXvt_m[\w \S¯nsb¶v Häs¸«
dnt¸mÀ«pIfneqsSsb¦nepw D²cn¡s¸«n«nÃ. \_n(kz)¡v AhcpsS `mj
AdnbnÃmbncn¡psa¶ Dulmt]mlw icnbÃ.''
Hcp aZvl_nsâbpw ]n³_ew
Cu Xd{]kwK¯n\nsöv D]cypà hniZoIcW¯n \n¶v {KmlyamIpw. |