D¯cw: ^XvlpÂapCu\nsâ
cNbnXmhmb _lp. ssk\p±o\p aJvZqw(d) ]dbp¶p: ""kemw ho«nb tijw
Camw ZpB sN¿pt¼mÄ aAvaqapIÄ¡v ZpB¡v Bao³ ]dbemtWm kz´ambn
hmcnZmb ZpB sN¿emtWm Gähpw D¯asa¶v Fsâ DkvXmZv _lp. C_v\plPÀ(d)t\mSv
Rm³ tNmZn¨p. At¸mÄ AhÀ C§s\ adp]Sn ]dªp. þCamansâ hmcnZmb {]mÀY\
aAvaqapIÄ tIÄ¡p¶psh¦n Bao³ ]dbemWv AhÀ¡v kp¶¯v.þ hopw aJvZqw(d)
]dbp¶p. Camav ZpB sN¿pt¼mÄ AXv tIÄ¡Â sImv am{Xw ZpBAv
aAvaqapIÄ¡v a\x]mTam¡m³ Ignbnsöv Caman\v t_m[ys¸«m aAvaqapIÄ
Bao³ ]db Dt±in¨psImv ZpB Dds¡bm¡emtWm AXà ]Xps¡bm¡emtWm kp¶s¯¶pw
ZpB kz´ambn a\x]mTapÅ aAvaqapIÄ¡v Camansâ ZpB¡v Bao³ ]dbemtWm
AXà Camant\msSm¸w kz´mbn ZpB sN¿emtWm kp¶s¯¶pw Rm³ tNmZn¨t¸mÄ
Fsâ DkvXmZv A_vZp AkoknÊwkan(d) C§s\ adp]Sn ]dªp. þ]e{]mhiyw
BhÀ¯n¨mhÀ¯n¨msW¦nepw Caman \n¶v ZpB AhÀ tIÄ¡pt¼mÄ a\x]mTam¡m³
km[yXbpÅXpsImv Camw D¨¯n ZpB sN¿emWv thsX¶v ^pJlmCsâ s]mXp
D²cWnIfn \n¶v {Kln¡m hp¶XmWv. am{XaÃ, Camansâ ZpBAv AhÀ
tIÄ¡pt¼mÄ Bao³ ]dbpsa¶pIm D¨¯n ZpB sN¿m\pÅ t{]cWbmWsX¶v Camw
kÀIin(d) ]dªn«pv. CXn \n¶pw shdpw Bao³ ]db Dt±in¨psImv Xs¶
Camw D¨¯n ZpB sN¿emWv Gähpw D¯asa¶pw aAvaqapIÄ ZpB a\x]mTapÅhcmsW¦nepw
Camansâ ZpBC\v Bao³ ]dbemWv \ÃsX¶pw {Kln¡mhp¶XmWv.'' _lp.
DkvXmZv A_vZpÂdDu^v(d) C{]Imcw ]dbp¶p: shdpw tIÄhnsImv aAvaqan\v
a\x]mTam¡m³ Ignbnsænepw Bao³ ]dbm³ thn Camw D¨¯nem¡emWv Gähpw
D¯aw. ImcWw Bao³ ]dbp¶h³ Iqenbn ZpB sN¿p¶hsâ ]¦mfnbmWv'' (_lp.
aJvZqw X§fpsS AÂAPvhn_Xp APo_. t]Pv 18, 18).
C_v\plPÀ(d) ]dbp¶p: ""ZpB
D¨¯nem¡p¶Xn\pÅ t{]cI Imcy§Ä CÃmXncn¡pt¼mÄ ]Xps¡bm¡emWv kp¶¯v. F¶mÂ
Camansâ {]mÀY\¡v aAv aqapIÄ Bao³ ]dbp¶Xv {]kvXpX t{]cI Imcy§fnÂ
s]«XmsW¶v Camw kÀIin(d) hyàam¡nbn«pv'' (A ^Xmh Ip_vd 1/158).
C¸dª ]WvVnX·mscÃmw im^nCu
aZvl_pImcsÃt¶m {]kvXpX {KÙ§Ä im^nCu aZvl_nse {]_e {KÙ§fsÃt¶m
]dbm³ BÀ¡pw IgnbnÃ. F ¶m CXpXs¶bmWv _lp. aJvZqw X§Ä ^XvlpÂ
apCu³ t]Pv 78Â ]dªXv.
auehnamÀ AwKoIcn¡p¶
hyànbpw Hcp aZvl_pw AwKoIcn¡msX shdpw lZokv sImv am{Xw Aa sN¿p¶
hyànbpamb A_vZpdlvam³ ap_mdIv ^qcn ]dbp¶p: ""\nkvImcm\´cw ZpB \S¯p¶Xv
\_n(kz)bpsS hm¡n \n ¶pw {]hr¯nbn \n¶pw Øncs¸«XmsW¶Xn kwibanÃ.
F¶m C¡me ¯v lZokv ]WvVnX·mÀ Cu hnjb¯n A`n{]mb `n¶XbnemWv.
IqSpXemfpIfpw ]dbp¶Xv Camw ZpB sN¿pIbpw aAvaqapIÄ Bao³ ]dbpIbpw
sN¿Wsa¶mWv. Npcp¡w NnecmWv AXv \ÃXsöv hmZn¡p¶Xv. \_n(kz)bn \n
¶§s\ Øncs¸«n«nsömWhÀ sXän²cn¨ncn¡p¶Xv'' (Xplv^Xp AlvhZn
2/170).
C^mfXp A³hmÀ t]Pv 182Â
]dbp¶p: ""Cu [mcW icnbsöpw CÆnjb¯nepÅ kXyw Alvep lZokn \n¶pÅ
BZyI£nIÄ ]dbp¶XmsW¶pw Xplv^Xp AlvhZnbpsS hm¡n \n¶pw [z\n¡p¶p.''
AÃmam A³hÀjm ]dbp¶p:
""\nkvImcm\´capÅ ZpB A\ntj[yamw hn[w {]kn²amsW¶Xn kwibanÃ'' (ss^fpÂ_mcn
4/417).
C_v\pssXan¿bpw C_v\pÂJ¿napw
C¶pÅ Nnesct¸mse CXv ]mtS _nZvA¯msW¶v hmZn¨n«nÃ. {]kvXpX C¶v kp¶nIÄ
sN¿p¶t]mse A¡mes¯ kp¶nIfpw \nc´cambn FÃm ^Àfv \nkvImcm\´chpw C§s\
sNbvXpt]mcp¶ ]Xnhns\bmWv AhÀ _nZvA¯msW¶v hntijn¸n¨Xv.
C_v\pJ¿nw Xsâ CAvemapÂ
aqJnCu³ 2/303Â ]dbp¶p: ""C¶p ImWp¶t]mse Camw Xncnªncp¶v ZpB
sN¿pIbpw aAvaqapIÄ Bao³ ]dbpIbpw sNbvXpsImncn¡p¶ k{¼Zmbw _nZvA¯mWv.
C§s\ \nc´cambn \_n (kz)bpw kzlm_¯pw sNbvXXmbn
D²cn¡s¸«n«nÃ.'' CXpt]mse C_v\pssXan¿ ^Xmh 2/212epw ]dªn«pv.
lnPvd F«mw \qämn acn¨
Cu cv hyànIfpsS D²cWnbn \n¶pw cpImcyw hyàamWv. H¶v: \nc´camb
Iq«{]mÀY\ C¶s¯t]mse Xs¶ A¶pw FÃmbnS¯pw \S¸pÅ Imcyambncp¶p.
FXncmfnIÄ ]dbp¶t]mse tIcf¯n se apkvenbm¡Ä Dm¡nbXÃ. cv: FÃm \nkvImcm\´chpw
C§s\ \nXyambn sN¿p¶ ]XnhmWv _nZvA¯v. CS¡nsS Hgnhm¡nbm _nZvA¯nÂ
\n¶pw c£s¸Sp¶XmWv. F¶m Cu A`n{]mbw Xs¶bmWv asämcp AlvepÂ
lZokpImc\mb A_qCkvlmJpÈmXzn_nbpsS ]£hpw.
CXn \ns¶Ãmw \nkvImcm\´c
Iq«{]mÀY\ ]mtS \njn²amsW¶v Alvep lZokpImcmb Cu ]WvVnX·mÀ¡v
t]mepw A`n{]mbansöpw AXnt\mSpÅ AeÀPn tIcf¯nse NneÀ¡p am{XamsW¶pw
kv]jvSambn. ]t£, PamA¯pImÀ A¸sam¶v Xmtgm«nd§nbn«pv. 1988 P\phcn
cnse {]t_m[\¯n C §s\ ]dbp¶p: ""\nkvImcm\´cw X\n¨v {]mÀYn¡p¶XmWv
Gsd D¯asa¦n epw Iq«mbn {]mÀYn¡p¶Xv \njn²amsW¶v Øm]n¡p¶
sXfnhpIfnÃ.'' CXn s\ ]cmaÀin¨v apPmlnZv hmcnIbn Hcp tNmZy¯n\p¯cambn
FgpXp¶p: ""Iq«{]mÀY\ \_n(kz)bpsSbpw kzlm_¯nsâbpw Ncybsöv
hyàambn«pw AXv \njn²amsW¶v ]dbp¶Xn\v sXfnhnsöv ]dbp¶Xv ]cnlmkyamsW¶pw
A XpsImpXs¶ PamA¯pImÀ kakvX apkvenbm¡·mcpsS hmZ¯nte¡v
XcwXmWpt]msb¶pw hyàamWv.''
CXn\p adp]Snbmbn {]t_m[\w
hmcnI e¡w 37 hmeyw 46 P\phcn 30Â hopw FgpXp¶p: ""Hcp hmZw Xcw
XmWtXm Xcws]m´nbtXm F¶v Xocpam\nt¡Xv AXnsâ hàm¡Ä kakvX¡mtcm \ZvhXpImtcm
F¶v t\m¡nbn«msW¶ Adnhv Cu teJI\nÃ. hmZ¯nsâ \ymb§fpw {]amW§fpamWv
am\ZWvUamt¡sX¶mWv a\Ênem¡nbn«pÅXv. \nkvImcm\´cw C¶s¯ coXnbnÂ
Iq«{]mÀY\ \S¯p¶Xn ]cnKW\obamb Zo\o XmXv]cy§tfm \ymb§tfm DÅXmbn
t_m[ys¸Sm¯Xv sImmWv CXv D¯aaÃ, \njn²hpaà F¶v teJI³ ]dªXv. F¶mÂ
A§s\ Nne XmXv]cy§fpÅXmbn a\Ênem¡pIbpw AX\pkcn¨v Iq«{]mÀY\
A`nImayamsW¶v hmZn¡pIbpw sNbvX ]qÀÆIme ]Wv VnX·mÀ [mcmfapv. {]hmNIsâ
k{¼ZmbaÃm¯XpsImv A`nejWobasöv hmZn¨hcpw \nch[nbpv. ]t£,
\njn²amsW¶v hmZn¨hsc Cu teJI³ AdnbnÃ. l\^o, amenIn, l¼en
aZvl_pIfnse ]WvVnX·mÀ kzp_vln, AkzÀ F¶o \nkvImc§Ä¡v tijw
Iq«{]mÀY\ A`nImayamsW¶v hmZn¨p. Cu \nkvImc§Ä¡v tijw kp¶¯v \nkvImcanÃ
F¶mWhcpsS \ymbw. im ^nCu ]WvVnX·mÀ FÃm \nkvImc§Ä¡p tijhpw
Iq«{]mÀY\ A`nImayamsW¶v \nÀt±in¨p. {]mÀY\ icoA¯v t{]mÕmln¸n¨
ImcyamsW¶mWhcpsS \ymbw'' (^Xmhm C_v\pssXan¿ 22/492).
Ahscms¡ kakvX
apkvenbm¡·msc t]mse XcwXmWhcmbncpt¶m Ft´m?
C_v\pssXan¿bpsS \m¸Xv
hmfy§fpÅ aPvaqDÂ ^XmhbpsS Ccp]¯ncmw hmfy¯nÂ\n¶pw {]t_m[\w hmcnI
D²cn¨ D²cWn At±l¯nsâ A©v hmey§fpÅ ^Xmh Ip_vd 1/189epw ImWmhp¶XmWv.
C{Xbpw hniZoIcn¨Xn \n¶pw
\mev aZvl_nsâ ]WvVnX·mcpw \nkvImcm\´cw Iq«{]mÀY\ AwKoIcn¨hcpw
C§s\ {]mÀYn¡p¶XmWv kz´w {]mÀYn¡p¶Xns\¡mÄ D¯asa¶v ]dbp¶hcpamsW¶v
hyàambn.
hgn]ng¨h\pw aäpÅhsc
hgn]ng¸n¡p¶h\pamsW¶v CÊp_v\p PamAXv(d), Camw kp_vIn(d), Camw C_v\plPÀ(d)
XpS§nbhÀ hntijn¸n¨ C_v\pssXan¿bpw At±ls¯ AwKoIcn¡p¶ C_v\pJ¿nw,
imXzn_n XpS§nbhcpw \nc´cambn CXv ]Xnhm¡p¶Xv am{XamWv A]e]n¨Xv.
CXv icnbsöv sXfnbn¨psImv [mcmfw lZokpIÄ D²cn¨ tijw _lp. bqkp^pÂ
_n¶qcn(d) aBcn^pÊp\³ 3/123Â ]dbp¶p: Cu lZokpIfpw CXpt]mse aäp
lZokpIfpw C¶v kÀÆP\§fpw \ncmt£]w ]Xnhm¡nt¸m¶ Iq«{]mÀY\¡v aXnbmb
sXfnhpIfmWv.
FÃm Ime¯pw temI
apkvenwIÄ ]c¼cmKXambn A\pjvTn¨pt]m¶ Hcp {] hr¯ns¡Xncn lZokv
sXfnªm Xs¶bpw B lZokn\v {]m_eyansöpw \ncmt£]apÅ apkvenwIfpsS
{]hr¯n¡mWv {]kànbpÅsX¶pw C_v\pJ ¿nw Xs¶ ImcyImcW klnXw Xsâ
CAvemap aqJnCu³ 2/306 kaÀYn¨n«pv.
Iq«{]mÀY\ temI
apkvenwIfpsS ap³Ime BNmcamsW¶v C_v\pssXan¿bpw C_v\pJ¿napw
imXzn_nbpw hyàam¡nbXv a\Ênem¡nbtÃm. JpXzp_ ]cn`mjbpw kv{Xo PpapA
PamA¯pw tIcf¯nepSseSp¯Xv bYm{Iaw sIm¨n, HXmbn ]ÅnIfnemsW¶v DaÀ
auehn kÂk_oen hyàam¡nbn«pv. Jp Xzp_ ]cn`mj temI¯mZyambn
DSseSp¯Xv XpÀ¡nbnemsW¶v ChcpsS {]Øm\¯nsâ t\Xmhmb dioZpcnfm X^vkodpÂ
a\mÀ 9/313Â hyàam¡nbn«pv. CXpsImpXs¶ AXv ]pXpXmbn DSseSp¯ _nZvA¯mWsX¶v
kp¶nIÄ ]dbp¶p. F¶m C¶ Øe¯pÅ C¶ ]Ånbn C¶ hÀj¯n BZyambn \nkvImcm\´c
Iq«{]mÀY\ XpS§pIbpw AXv ]n¶oSv hym]IamhpIbpw sNbv Xpsh¶v CXv _nZvA¯msW¶v
hmZn¡p¶hÀ¡v Øm]n¡m³ Hcn¡epw IgnbnÃ. |